Though purists will no doubt scoff, bottled barbeque sauce is not some great sin unto the world. Many of the best options are simplified versions of sauces made by pitmasters you or I could never hope to match.

But like most goods previously made in the home, store-bought sauce can also suck. Sometimes terribly so. The trap many fall into is excess in one of the four pillars of barbeque-sauce flavor — heat, smokiness, tanginess and, the most commonly abused, sweetness. We scoured the web, grocery stores and barbeque forums to find out which retail-available, bottled barbeque sauces are actually worth putting on the meat you’ve spend all day smoking.

The Short List

Stubb’s Original Bar-B-Q Sauce

Though Texans aren’t prone to using sauces in the first place, Stubb’s Texas-style original sauce is as good as anyone can hope for out of a bottle. The first thing you’ll notice is that it is decidedly unsweet for a bottled sauce. It also has zero high fructose corn syrup and doesn’t use any artificial ingredients.

Stubb’s opts instead for a tomato- and vinegar-forward sauce that’s way overall less overpowering than most things from a bottle. The longer you eat, the more smokiness and spiciness you’ll begin to feel, but it’s not what you’d describe as a particularly smoky or spicy. It simply balanced, as all sauces should be.

Jack Daniel’s Original No. 7 Recipe Barbecue Sauce

The label says “HICKORY SMOKE FLAVOR” and it means it. This is as smoky a sauce as you’ll find in a bottle, but not so much it drowns other flavors out; it’s fairly peppery and has a lot of body as well. If you like super-sweet sauces, this one might not be for you — though a quick simmer with a bit of honey and butter might do the trick.

Rufus Teague Blazin’ Hot Sauce

It’s not that hot, which is just what it ought to be. Rufus Teague’s sauces are typically well-balanced and non-destructive to your health. They’re also available in grocery stores across the country. This one is made with totally natural ingredients (read: no high fructose corn syrup) and contains more interesting ingredients than most sauces do, homemade or bottled. The heat stems from chili pepper then chipotle, but it isn’t an overly aggressive burn. If the heat is indeed too much, consider tossing a couple pads of butter into a saucepan with it.

What to Know About Popular Styles of Sauce

Kansas City Style: The most widely available style of barbeque sauce at grocery stores is at its best a balanced mix of tomato (ketchup, most of the time), sweetness, tang and smoke. This is the gloopy reddish-brown sauce you slather all over ribs — it’s great for its strong hold to meats and overall body as well.

Texas Style: Sometimes called “mop sauce” or “mop style,” these are sauces with a tomato and vinegar base. They’re typically much lighter in body than KC-style sauces, but not as light as a Carolinian vinegar sauces. They’re also applied with a lighter hand than most sauces, and feature lots of garlic, black pepper and worchestire sauce.

Lexington Style (North Carolina): Though some of North Carolina’s population may protest, this is essentially an earlier version of the uber-popular Kansas City sauce, sans-spiciness and with a lot more tomato product. If you don’t like the spiciness and bite that comes with a lot of KC sauces, this style is for you.

East North Carolina Vinegar-Based: It’s vinegar, pepper, salt and pepper flakes. The most fluid sauce there is gets most of its flavor from the tart vinegar and various pepper flakes and pepper powders added (cayenne being the most common). It may not be all that useful in caramelizing the outside of a pig, but it’s still delicious.

Other Good Options

Bull’s Eye Original BBQ Sauce

Though a bit heavier in high fructose corn syrup than you’d like, Bull’s Eye’s sauce is a great grocery store sauce pickup. Serious Eats, Cooks Illustrated and America’s Test Kitchen spoke of it too, but the sauce is as balanced as it gets without making it yourself — it sits in the middle on the sweetness scale, it’s smokier than most store-bought bottles, it’s not overly spicy (but isn’t boring) and it has enough body to cling to whatever you baste it to. If you can get past the ingredient list, it’s great.

Trader Joe’s Carolina Gold Sauce

It’s mustard-based and has pure cane sugar — two rarities in barbeque sauces, generally, made especially more rare in the bottled market. If you’ve not had it, cane sugar has a slightly different flavor than what we’re used to, and it works extremely well with tangy mustard. This sauce, in particular, is especially incredible on a Boston butt, though it’s good on pretty much any charred meats — from pork shoulder to brats.

Bone Suckin’ Sauce

A bit sweeter than your usual fare, to the point it might remind you of a sweet and sour sauce. Fortunately, sweet and sour sauce is delicious, and this one has the added benefit of a mild hickory smoke flavor that manages to not taste like chemicals. It is a bit thinner than KC-style sauce, so if you want it to stick to ribs consider cooking it down for a few minutes on the stove.

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que Sensuous Slathering Sauce

Not as widely available as the others on this list, but a treat if you can find it — Sensuous Slathering sauce is one of the lowest-sugar bottled sauces out there and, frankly, it doesn’t need it. It gets a bit of augmented sweetness from bell pepper and it’s wickedly smokey and tangy. The consistency is such that it’s ready to baste right out of the bottle. There’s no corn syrup of any kind in it and you can probably pronounce every ingredient in its makeup.