Listen up, Goldilocks. We found a pillow that’s as soft or as firm as you need. Authenticity50, the American-made seed-to-stitch bedding company, just restocked its Custom Comfort Pillows, which have sold out like clockwork since their 2019 release.

The pillows are filled with shredded memory foam and microfiber blend for optimal head and neck support, minus the overheating of a standard memory foam pillow. Sleepers can remove or add fill to achieve their desired firmness level. If the pillow still isn’t firm enough, reach out to Authenticity50, and the brand will send extra fill for free. To clean the pillow, simply remove the outer cover and throw it in the wash. The brand recommends doing this once or twice a year (droolers should do so more often).

The Custom Comfort Pillows come in a standard ($69) and king ($79). Buy a two-pack to save some cash.

Note: Purchasing products through our links may earn us a portion of the sale, which supports our editorial team’s mission. Learn more here.