One lucky Reddit user has happened upon a modern-day Porsche conundrum and decided to throw the internet into an existential crisis. Would you take the Porsche 904 Carrera GTS or opt for the mid-2000s Porsche Carrera GT? A picture with a handful of words has never stumped us more than this.

Forty years separate the two cars. Both had limited runs with the GTS being built for just two years — 1964 and 1965. The GT has a slightly longer production run from 2003 to 2007. Power for the GTS came from a modest 198-hp 2.0-liter flat-four engine. The Carrera GT, on the other hand, had a 5.7-liter V10 making 612 hp and 435 lb-ft of torque.

Commenters seem split on which to pick. And honestly so are we. Pitting these two cars against each other is honestly comparing apples to high-performance, genetically modified oranges. Each has their merits and is so different; we’d rather take the road of indecisiveness and say we’d take both. We’re so greedy we’ll take that 959 on the lift, too.